Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing: What’s Best for Edmonton Weather?
If you’re planning a roof installation in Edmonton, your choice of material isn’t just about looks.
Between deep freezes, heavy snow, and sudden thaws, your roof takes a beating year-round, so the material you choose matters.
Asphalt and metal are two of the most common options, but they handle our wild weather in very different ways.
Knowing how each performs can save you money, stress, and mid-winter headaches.
Edmonton Weather Challenges for Roofs
Edmonton’s climate doesn’t go easy on buildings, especially rooftops.
Freeze-thaw cycles can crack or warp materials over time, while heavy snow loads test a roof’s weight tolerance and drainage.
Hailstorms are another big concern because they are fast, damaging, and unpredictable.
All of this means your roofing material needs to handle constant stress without giving out early.
Asphalt Shingles: The Traditional Favorite
Asphalt shingles are a go-to option for many Edmonton homeowners thanks to their affordability and ease of installation.
They come in a variety of styles and colors, making it simple to match your home’s look.
Most asphalt roofs last 15–25 years with proper care, which works well for many budgets.
But their popularity doesn’t mean they’re perfect for our climate.
Pros of Asphalt Shingles in Edmonton
Cost-effective upfront, making them an accessible choice for most homeowners
Easy to find and quick to install, with plenty of experienced contractors available
Good performance in moderate weather and decent resistance to wind
Repairs are relatively simple and inexpensive compared to other materials
Insulates well in mild seasons, helping manage interior temperatures
Cons of Asphalt Shingles in Our Climate
Can crack or curl due to extreme cold and repeated freeze-thaw cycles
More vulnerable to damage from hail compared to metal options
Snow and ice buildup can shorten their lifespan and cause leaks
UV exposure in long summer days may speed up wear and fading
Typically need replacement sooner than metal in harsh climates like Edmonton’s
Metal Roofing: The Modern Contender
Metal roofing is gaining popularity across Alberta, and for good reason.
Most systems are made from steel or aluminum, with protective coatings that help resist rust, corrosion, and UV damage.
It’s a sleek, durable option that often outlasts traditional shingles by decades.
Metal panels can be styled to look like shingles, tiles, or standing seams, offering both function and curb appeal.
Advantages of Metal Roofing for Alberta Homes
Extremely durable against snow, ice, and hail—ideal for Alberta’s unpredictable weather
Long lifespan (often 40–70 years), reducing long-term replacement costs
Sheds snow easily, helping prevent ice dams and added weight
Fire-resistant and low-maintenance, adding peace of mind
Can improve energy efficiency by reflecting sunlight and reducing heat gain
Downsides of Metal Roofing to Consider
Higher upfront cost compared to asphalt, which may be a barrier for some budgets
Installation requires specialized skills and can take longerMay be noisier during rain or hail without proper insulation
Dents are possible with large hail, depending on the metal thickness
Limited availability of certain colors or finishes in some regions
Performance Comparison: Asphalt vs. Metal
When it comes to a roof replacement in Edmonton, choosing between asphalt and metal roofing comes down to more than just looks.
It’s about how each one performs in real-life conditions.
Both materials have strengths, but they serve homeowners differently over time.
Durability and Lifespan
Asphalt shingles typically last 15–25 years, depending on maintenance and weather exposure.
Metal roofing can go 40 years or more with minimal issues, making it a long-term investment.
In Edmonton’s harsh climate, that difference adds up quickly.
Metal stands up better to wind, ice, and thermal movement.
Asphalt may need roofing repairs or full replacement much sooner.
Energy Efficiency in Hot and Cold Seasons
Metal reflects sunlight, which helps keep homes cooler in the summer.
Some systems also have insulating layers to reduce heat loss in winter.
Asphalt absorbs more heat, which can be helpful in colder months but less efficient in summer.
If your attic isn’t well insulated, asphalt may lead to temperature swings indoors.
For energy-conscious upgrades, metal usually has the edge.
Maintenance Requirements
Asphalt shingles need regular inspections, looking for curling, missing pieces, or moss buildup.
Metal roofing is more hands-off, with occasional checks for dents, sealant wear, or debris in seams.
Snow removal is usually easier on metal thanks to its smooth surface.
Asphalt might trap snow or ice, especially near eaves.
Less maintenance means less hassle over time with metal.
Cost Differences Over Time
Asphalt is cheaper up front, making it appealing for immediate budgets.
But over 30–40 years, it may need to be replaced once or even twice.
Metal roofing costs more at the start, but typically doesn’t need replacement within that same window.
Add in lower maintenance and better energy savings, and metal often pays off long-term.
It’s about what you’re willing to pay now versus later.
Hail and Snow Resistance
Edmonton hailstorms can be brutal, and metal roofing handles them better overall.
Thicker panels resist denting, and protective coatings help avoid corrosion.
Asphalt shingles are more likely to crack or lose granules after a big storm.
Snow also slides off metal more easily, reducing the risk of ice dams and leaks.
For sheer weather resistance, metal is the stronger option.
Local Regulations and Insurance Considerations
Before starting a roof installation, it’s important to know what’s allowed and what’s preferred.
Building codes in the city may have specific requirements around fire ratings, wind resistance, and snow load capacity, depending on your roofing material.
Some insurance providers also offer lower premiums for metal roofing due to its fire and hail resistance.
Others may ask for additional documentation or inspections based on your material choice.
What Roofing Material Is Best for You?
Choosing the right roof isn’t just about bracing for Edmonton’s wild weather.
It’s also about what fits your home, budget, and long-term plans.
Asphalt and metal both offer strong benefits, but the right choice depends on your priorities.
Budget vs. Long-Term Value
If you’re working with a tight budget, asphalt shingles make the initial install more affordable.
But if you can stretch your investment, metal roofing offers lower maintenance costs and fewer replacements over time.
It’s the difference between paying less now or saving more later.
Aesthetic and Resale Considerations
Asphalt shingles come in a wide range of colors and styles, blending easily with most neighbourhoods.
Metal has a more modern, high-end look that can boost curb appeal, especially on contemporary or custom homes.
In resale terms, metal may give your home an edge with buyers who value durability and energy efficiency.
Just make sure the look fits the style of your house.
Home Type and Roof Pitch Factors
The slope and shape of your roof can affect which material performs better.
Metal roofing works well on low- or steep-pitched roofs and sheds snow efficiently.
Asphalt may be a better fit for complex rooflines with multiple valleys or dormers, where flexible materials make installation easier.
Your home’s structure plays a big role in what’s most practical.
Ready for a Roof Replacement in Edmonton?
Thinking about upgrading your roof?
Soltek makes it easy!
We handle everything from permits and engineering to installation and rebates, so you don’t have to stress the details.
Get in touch for a free quote and see how we can help with your roof replacement in Edmonton.